Skip to main content

Table of Contents

Introduction

HNI investors asking this question are almost always asking the wrong version of it.

The right question is not which asset class delivers better returns in isolation. It is which asset class, with which manager, over which horizon, earns those returns net of fees, taxes, and opportunity cost.

Private equity and public markets do not compete for the same portfolio slot. They serve different functions and reward patience differently. This post lays out that comparison. No advocacy. Just a framework for thinking through it.

How Each Asset Class Generates Returns

Public markets create wealth through ownership of listed businesses whose earnings compound over time. When you hold quality companies through a PMS, you participate in revenue growth, margin expansion, and reinvestment of free cash flows. Over a long horizon, share price tracks intrinsic value. Volatility is noise around that signal.

Private equity creates value through operational transformation. A PE fund acquires a business, restructures its capital, and exits at a higher valuation multiple. Returns come from earnings growth, multiple expansion, and leverage during the holding period.

Both approaches create real wealth. The mechanics, timelines, and execution skill sets are structurally different.

The Return Picture

Aggregate return comparisons are frequently cited and frequently misleading.

Indian public equity benchmarks have delivered roughly 12 to 14 percent CAGR over 20-year horizons. That figure is real, auditable, and what a disciplined equity PMS has historically provided.

PE returns are reported differently. IRR calculations can flatter performance if measured before an exit is realised. The more grounded metric is DPI (Distributions to Paid-In Capital). A fund with a 20 percent IRR and a DPI of 0.8x has not yet returned invested capital.

Top-quartile PE funds have outperformed public benchmarks. Median PE funds have not. Identifying top-quartile managers requires access and due diligence most HNIs do not have independently.

Liquidity and the Cost of Lock-In

Public markets offer daily liquidity. You can exit a position, rebalance, or respond to a tax planning need within a single trading day.

Private equity requires a 7 to 10 year commitment in Category II AIF structures. Capital is drawn through staged capital calls, and distributions come as exits occur. The illiquidity premium is compensation for surrendering that access over a long cycle.

The question is whether that premium is actually being earned. At a 15 percent IRR when a PMS compounded at 14 percent, the premium is marginal. The calculus changes if the PE fund targets 20 to 25 percent IRR with strong sector tailwinds.

Risk Is Not the Same in Both Worlds

Public market risk is visible. Mark-to-market valuations update daily and drawdowns are measurable. That visibility creates psychological pressure during corrections, but it ensures full transparency.

Private equity risk is opaque by design. Unlisted company valuations are updated periodically, exit risk is real when markets contract, and manager risk is high because the value creation thesis depends entirely on the GP’s execution.

PE is not necessarily riskier in absolute terms. But the risks are harder to monitor and harder to exit.

When Private Equity Makes Sense

Private equity belongs in a portfolio when specific conditions are genuinely met, not as a default allocation above a wealth threshold.

It makes sense when you have capital that is structurally surplus for 7 to 10 years. It makes sense when you can access a manager with a demonstrable track record, meaningful carried interest alignment, and sector expertise where listed exposure is limited.

A thoughtful PE commitment is typically 10 to 15 percent of investable assets, not a token position.

When Public Markets Make More Sense

Public markets make more sense when liquidity, transparency, and long-horizon compounding are the priorities.

The BSE 500 today includes businesses across chemicals, specialty finance, capital goods, and healthcare that lacked listed presence a decade ago. A quality-focused PMS, with direct ownership and the flexibility to rebalance as fundamentals evolve, is a structurally sound strategy.

For India’s Amritkaal vision to materialise into investor wealth by 2047, the businesses executing on that vision will largely be listed. The public market is where that wealth compounds.

Structural Comparison

ParameterPrivate Equity (Cat II AIF)Public Markets (PMS)
Minimum InvestmentRs.1 croreRs. 50 lakh
Liquidity7 to 10 year lock-inGenerally liquid
Return MetricIRR, DPI, MOICTWRR, XIRR
Valuation FrequencyPeriodicDaily mark-to-market
Tax StructurePass-through (Cat I and II)Direct equity tax treatment
TransparencyModerate (via PPM)Full (demat, broker reports)
Return Potential18 to 25%+ top-quartile12 to 16% quality PMS
Investor ProfileLong horizon, surplus capitalGrowth-oriented, flexible

About Carnelian

Carnelian Asset Management works with HNIs navigating exactly this allocation question. Our PMS strategies are built around quality businesses at reasonable valuations. Our AIF offerings provide access to private market opportunities for investors with the right horizon.

If you are evaluating how to position your portfolio across public and private markets, reach out to our team.

FAQs

1. Can an HNI invest in both private equity and public markets simultaneously?
Yes. Most HNIs anchor in a quality-focused equity PMS while allocating 10 to 20 percent to a Category II AIF. The two asset classes complement rather than compete.

2. How should I evaluate a PE fund’s performance claims?
Focus on DPI over IRR. DPI measures actual cash returned. An IRR of 25 percent means little if capital has not yet been distributed. Check vintage year and the market conditions under which those returns were generated.

3. How does taxation differ between a PMS and a Category II AIF?
In a PMS, every trade is a taxable event under your PAN. LTCG applies at 12.5 percent and STCG at 20 percent. In a Category II AIF, the structure is pass-through: you are taxed on income and gains as if received directly, at your applicable slab rates.

4. What is the role of MOIC in evaluating private equity returns?
MOIC (Multiple on Invested Capital) tells you how many times your original investment has grown. A MOIC of 2.5x means every rupee invested returned Rs. 2.50. Unlike IRR, MOIC ignores the time taken, so it is best read alongside IRR and DPI together.

5. Can NRIs invest in Category II AIFs in India?
Yes. NRIs can invest through NRE or NRO accounts, subject to FEMA regulations and the fund’s eligibility criteria in its PPM. Tax treatment varies by residency status and applicable DTAA provisions. Consult a qualified tax advisor before committing.